U.S. Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.) today discussed the Democrats’ reckless tax-and-spending spree and the cost that would ultimately fall on the backs of hardworking middle-income families. Thune noted that the Democrats’ new death tax would force Americans to pay more money in taxes on assets passed on from generation to generation. Last week, Thune led the entire Senate Republican caucus in urging President Biden to abandon his effort to impose a capital gains tax increase on family-owned businesses, farms, and ranches.
Thune’s remarks below (as prepared for delivery):
“Mr. President, not content with their $1.9 trillion so-called ‘COVID relief’ bill – paid for entirely with money borrowed from younger generations of Americans and our children and grandchildren – Democrats are readying another partisan spending spree.
“Democrats are preparing to consider a $3.5 trillion tax-and-spending package, this one at least partially paid for … by massive tax hikes.
“Tax hikes on small businesses.
“Tax hikes on large businesses.
“Tax hikes on investment.
“Tax hikes on well-off Americans.
“And tax hikes on the middle class.
“Tax hikes on the middle class.
“Now, President Biden is fond of repeating that he won’t raise taxes on anyone making under $400,000.
“But the new death tax he’s proposing will definitely hit some middle-class Americans.
“Let’s talk about that new tax.
“President Biden and congressional Democrats are proposing to eliminate a part of the tax code known as step-up in basis, or stepped-up basis.
“Under our current tax code, when you inherit something from an estate – whether that’s stocks or a house – the value of that item is “stepped up” from its original value to its current market value when you receive it.
“This prevents you from having to pay capital gains taxes on the amount that your parents’ house increased in value when it was owned by your parents.
“Let’s say you inherit a house that your parents bought for $100,000 but is now worth $500,000.
“Under current law, when you inherit that house, you are not liable for taxes on the increase in value from the time your parents bought it.
“The house is transferred to you at its current market value of $500,000.
“So if you sell the house right when you inherit it, you will receive the full value of the house, instead of having to pay taxes on the amount that the house increased in value while your parents owned it.
“And if you sell that house two years later for $650,000, you’re only required to pay taxes on the $150,000 in value it gained while in your possession.
“Under Democrats’ proposal, however, capital gains taxes would automatically be triggered upon death if the increase in value of an individual’s estate has exceeded a certain amount.
“So if your parents’ house or the family farm or other assets have increased in value more than Democrats deem desirable, you would now owe capital gains taxes on the amount of that increase immediately after your parents’ death, minus the amount Democrats choose to exempt.
“And there are plenty of middle-class Americans around this country who would be paying this tax.
“You wouldn’t be protected just because you make under $400,000.
“Now, the president has tried to get around this by arguing that Democrats would be taxing dead individuals, not living ones.
“So if your parents die and pass on their estate, the argument suggests, the tax you have to send to the federal government isn’t a tax on you, but on your parents.
“Well, who does he think he’s fooling?
“Who is going to experience the loss of that money?
“You, or your parents?
“Who is going to be writing the check to the federal government?
“Let’s imagine that a woman’s parents die and leave her their estate and two weeks later a thief comes in and steals part of that inheritance.
“Who are people going to think was robbed?
“The daughter, or her deceased parents?
“I think all of us would recognize that it was the daughter who was robbed.
“The same thing applies to Democrats’ proposed new death tax.
“It’s not dead Americans who would be writing checks to the federal government.
“Sure, the tax is owed by the decedent or transferor, but for all practical purposes the costs would be borne by their descendants.
“But the truth is, Mr. President, even if we accepted the argument that Democrats’ new death tax is a tax on deceased Americans and not their descendants, this tax would still hit some middle-class Americans.
“After all, it’s perfectly possible to work hard your whole life and invest wisely and see your estate appreciate in value by more than $1.25 million – the proposed individual exemption level – over the course of your life without ever exiting the middle class.
“We’re not talking about confining this taxation to individuals with a yearly income of one and a quarter million.
“We’re talking about the increase in value on an estate over a person’s lifetime.
“There’s no question that this tax would fall on the estates of some thoroughly middle-class Americans.
“But, Mr. President, the problems with this new death tax aren’t limited to the fact that it breaks President Biden’s pledge not to raise taxes on individuals making under $400,000.
“There are a lot of additional problems – starting with the administration and compliance costs of this tax.
“Congress actually passed a similar proposal in the 1970s, but repealed it before it went into effect because it was so complicated and unworkable.
“Congress repealed the proposal before it was even implemented because it was clear that collecting this tax was going to be too complicated.
“Forty-odd years later, collecting this tax would still be an enormously complicated matter.
“It would put incredible new record-keeping requirements on a lot of American families.
“And it would strain the capabilities of the IRS – although those 87,000 new IRS employees President Biden wants to add to the agency would certainly increase the available manpower to levy new tax bills.
“Plus, I can only imagine the litigation that would arise over the valuation of assets.
“What happens if the IRS disagrees with the estimate of the value of your family farm or business?
“Do you have to take the IRS to court?
“Will the IRS take you to court?
“In addition, Mr. President, there’s a very real danger that Americans would be paying taxes on nonexistent gains, in part due to inflation and the natural expansion of the economy.
“Recent economic reports are raising concerns that, with the administration’s robust new entitlement spending, Americans could be shouldering the burdens of significant inflation now and long into the future.
“But Democrats’ new death tax would not account for inflation on an asset, like a family-owned farm or a business, which means Americans could be paying a lot of money in taxes on nonexistent gains.
“Finally, Mr. President, I want to talk about the threat this tax poses to family farms and businesses.
“Now Democrats claim that they will defer this tax for family farms and businesses as long as a member of the family inherits and then runs the farm or business.
“But it’s completely unclear what this will look like in practice.
“Will family members refer only to sons and daughters?
“What if a stepson wants to take over the farm? Or a niece?
“Will the inheritors still be subject to the tax then – which could result in their having to sell that farm the niece wants to run.
“What happens if two or more of the children want to run the farm?
“There are a lot of unanswered questions.
“And, of course, it’s important to remember that Democrats would only be deferring the tax.
“So if the time ever comes when the family wants to sell the farm – maybe it’s getting hard to run and a neighboring family is willing to buy it – the family would have to pay those taxes that were deferred when their mom or dad died.
“If that family farm has been handed down through a few generations already, it’s completely possible that paying those taxes would consume a big part of that legacy.
“There’s a reason 13 House Democrats sent a letter to House Democrat leaders expressing their concern about the proposed step-up in basis repeal.
“It’s because this tax would pose a real threat to the continued existence of family farms and businesses.
“It’s the same reason those in the agriculture and small business communities oppose this new death tax.
“I was proud to lead all 50 Senate Republicans in a letter last week urging President Biden to drop this misguided proposal.
“And I will continue to do everything I can to protect family farms and businesses from this new tax.
“Mr. President, there should be a limit to how many times the federal government can tax you.
“Americans’ bank accounts should not be regarded as a bottomless barrel of money to pay for Democrats’ preferred government programs.
“Because that’s exactly what’s happening here.
“Democrats want to massively – and permanently – expand government, and they’re looking to Americans and American businesses to pay for their social experiments.
“And they apparently haven’t spent much time considering how our economy – or American families – would suffer as a result of their tax-and-spending spree.
“Mr. President, middle-class Americans should not have to see their inheritances shrink to pay for Democrats’ spending.
“And family farms and businesses – who already face challenges from our current death tax – should not have to be worrying that a new death tax will spell the end of their hard-earned legacy.
“I hope Democrats will think twice before moving forward with this new tax increase on Americans.”